Setting Comparison in "The Escape" by Qaisra Shahraz
This page provides a detailed comparison of the settings in Qaisra Shahraz's short story "The Escape," contrasting urban Manchester with a rural village near Lahore. The comparison is structured around infrastructure and cultural aspects of both locations.
Manchester
Manchester is portrayed as a modern, diverse urban center with a complex infrastructure and multicultural population.
Infrastructure
The city is characterized by a mix of terraced houses and skyscrapers, with minimal green spaces. The urban landscape is dominated by large roads with heavy traffic, reflecting the city's bustling nature. A variety of shops, including those catering to different cultures, line the streets. The city's size and population density contribute to a sense of anonymity among residents.
Highlight: The description of Manchester emphasizes its urban complexity and the coexistence of various cultures within a single city environment.
Culture
The part of Manchester where Samir, a character in the story, resides is notably multicultural. This diversity is evident in the presence of various places of worship, including mosques and Catholic churches. The neighborhood is home to a mix of ethnicities and nationalities, including Pakistanis, Bengalis, Irish, Somalis, and Chinese.
Example: The multicultural aspect of Manchester is exemplified by the presence of diverse religious institutions and the cohabitation of multiple ethnic communities in a single neighborhood.
Village near Lahore
In contrast to Manchester, the village near Lahore is presented as a traditional, rural settlement with a focus on agriculture and simple living.
Infrastructure
The village landscape is dominated by fields and natural surroundings, indicating its agricultural focus. Housing consists of small, rustic dwellings with inner courtyards where small farm animals like chickens and goats are kept. A notable feature is the presence of a slaughterhouse behind the houses. The lack of modern amenities is evident, with cooking done in stone ovens and meals eaten on the ground.
Vocabulary: Rustic - characteristic of rural life, simple and unsophisticated.
Culture
The village's culture is markedly different from Manchester's diversity. Almost all inhabitants are Muslim, creating a homogeneous religious environment. The lack of cultural diversity stands in stark contrast to the multicultural setting of Manchester.
Definition: Cultural homogeneity refers to the similarity in cultural practices, beliefs, and values among members of a community.
This detailed comparison of settings in "The Escape" highlights the significant differences between urban and rural life, as well as the contrast between Western and South Asian cultures. These differences likely play a crucial role in the story's exploration of themes such as cultural identity, adaptation, and the concept of home.
