Writing a Comment: Structure and Argumentation

This page provides a comprehensive guide on how to write an effective comment, focusing on structure and argumentation techniques. It distinguishes between one-sided and two-sided comments, explaining the key elements and strategies for each type.

Types of Comments

1. One-sided Comment:

   • Contains only arguments supporting the writer's opinion
   • Uses the operator "comment on"

2. Two-sided Comment:

   • Includes arguments both for and against the writer's opinion
   • Uses the operator "discuss"

Main Elements of a Comment

Introduction

• Includes an "umbrella sentence" mentioning the source (e.g., newspaper, article, text, cartoon)
• Provides a short summary of the text or description of the cartoon
• Addresses the W-questions: When, where, by whom
• States the author's opinion

Highlight: The introduction sets the context and clearly states the author's position on the topic.

Main Part

• Presents arguments in a structured manner
• For one-sided comments: Arranges arguments from strongest to weakest
• For two-sided comments: Starts with the strongest argument against the author's opinion, followed by the strongest argument for it

Example: In a two-sided comment on climate change, you might start with the strongest argument against immediate action (economic costs) before presenting the strongest argument for it (long-term environmental benefits).

Conclusion

• Briefly repeats the major arguments
• Restates the author's opinion
• Provides a solution or outlook on the topic

Highlight: The conclusion reinforces the author's stance and offers a forward-looking perspective on the issue.

Writing Tips

• Ensure a clear structure throughout the comment
• Use persuasive language and logical reasoning
• Balance arguments in two-sided comments
• Maintain a consistent tone and style

Vocabulary: "Umbrella sentence" - An opening statement that encapsulates the main topic and source of the comment.

This guide provides a solid foundation for writing both Kommentar Beispieltext Schule and more advanced comments suitable for Deutsch Abitur Kommentar musterlösung. By following this structure and incorporating these elements, students can create well-organized and compelling comments on various topics.